Skip to contentpdufa.bio

Capricor and deramiocel: two Complete Response Letters

Page updated ·next FDA decision on the calendar ·Data as of Nov 21, 2026 10:10 PM ET

Capricor Therapeutics applied for approval of deramiocel for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) under BL 125842. The FDA issued a Complete Response Letter dated July 9, 2025, and Capricor announced a second one on November 20, 2026. This page sets the FDA's released letter beside the company's statements. Times are Eastern. Sources read 2026-11-21 and 2026-11-22. Facts only; no view on any outcome.

Where things stand

ApplicationBL 125842
First CRLdated July 9, 2025; the FDA's letter (PDF)
ResubmissionClass 2; PDUFA date August 22, 2026, moved to November 22, 2026 (Capricor)
Advisory committeeCapricor reports a vote of 3 for, 9 against, 0 abstain at the July 29, 2026 meeting; meeting page
Second CRLannounced by Capricor November 20, 2026, 7:55 p.m. ET, after the market close
Second letter's textnot in the FDA's CRL release as of the snapshot read for this page (2026-11-21; openFDA last updated 2026-11-18, before Capricor's November 20, 2026 announcement)

What the FDA's July 9, 2025 letter says

Quoted from the FDA's released letter (PDF); each quote is checked against the text of the letter in the FDA's own release (openFDA transparency/crl) every time this page is built.

TopicThe letter
Primary endpoint“The HOPE-2 study failed to demonstrate efficacy for its prespecified primary efficacy endpoint, which was change from baseline to Month 12 in the mid-level (elbow) dimension of the Performance of Upper Limb version 1.2 (PUL 1.2)”
Study design“As stated in your response to an FDA information request […] the HOPE-2 study was intended to evaluate the effectiveness of deramiocel on neuromuscular function and was not designed to assess effectiveness for the treatment of cardiomyopathy in patients with DMD” (The date of the information request is redacted in the released letter.)
Secondary and exploratory endpoints“include 50 secondary and exploratory endpoints, including post hoc analyses of 26 endpoints of cardiac MRI assessments”
Multiplicity“no prespecified multiplicity adjustment strategy was employed for control of the overall Type 1 error rate”
Conclusion“Your BLA does not meet the statutory requirement for substantial evidence of effectiveness.”
What the FDA recommended“If you wish to seek approval of deramiocel for treatment of cardiomyopathy in patients with DMD, we recommend that you conduct adequate and well-controlled study(ies), whose primary objective is evaluation of cardiac outcomes in deramiocel-treated patients with DMD cardiomyopathy, compared to a randomized, concurrent control group over an appropriate duration of follow up”
Deadline“Within one year after the date of this letter, you are required to resubmit or withdraw the application”

The letter also has sections headed “Chemistry, Manufacturing, and Controls (CMC)” and “CMC [Facility and Equipment]”. In the released text the pages after these headings are blank and the numbered items resume at item 13, so what the FDA wrote about manufacturing is not in the released version.

The letter and the company, side by side

TopicFDA letter, July 9, 2025Capricor
Effectiveness"Your BLA does not meet the statutory requirement for substantial evidence of effectiveness."July 11, 2025: the release quotes the same finding.
The study asked for"If you wish to seek approval of deramiocel for treatment of cardiomyopathy in patients with DMD", a study "whose primary objective is evaluation of cardiac outcomes" against "a randomized, concurrent control group".September 25, 2025: "The HOPE-3 clinical trial should serve as the 'additional study' requested in the CRL."
Manufacturing (CMC)The released letter has a CMC section and a "CMC [Facility and Equipment]" section; no text under either appears in the released version.July 11, 2025: CMC materials "were not reviewed by the FDA due to the timing of the CRL issuance". September 25, 2025: "All CMC items identified in the CRL have been addressed and communicated to the FDA."
Publication of the letterThe FDA released the letter under its CRL transparency program.September 9, 2025: Capricor was "not notified in advance that the CRL would be posted".

Timeline

Date (ET)WhoWhat the source saysSource
July 9, 2025FDAThe FDA's Complete Response Letter for BLA 125842 is dated July 9, 2025.FDA letter (PDF)
July 11, 2025, 6:30 a.m.CapricorCapricor announces the CRL. It quotes the FDA's finding that the BLA "does not meet the statutory requirement for substantial evidence of effectiveness" and says CMC review materials "were not reviewed by the FDA due to the timing of the CRL issuance".Capricor release
September 9, 2025, 9:20 a.m.CapricorAfter the FDA posts the letter, Capricor says it was "not notified in advance that the CRL would be posted".Capricor release
September 25, 2025, 7:15 a.m.CapricorAfter a Type A meeting, Capricor says "The HOPE-3 clinical trial should serve as the 'additional study' requested in the CRL" and "All CMC items identified in the CRL have been addressed and communicated to the FDA."Capricor release
December 3, 2025, 7:20 a.m.CapricorCapricor reports HOPE-3 topline results: primary endpoint PUL v2.0 (n=105), p=0.029; key secondary endpoint LVEF (n=83), p=0.041.Capricor release
March 10, 2026, 9:25 a.m.CapricorCapricor says the FDA classified the resubmission as Class 2 with a PDUFA date of August 22, 2026, and that "the FDA has not identified any potential review issues".Capricor release
June 26, 2026, 10:02 a.m.CapricorCapricor announces an FDA advisory committee meeting on the BLA for July 29, 2026.Capricor release
July 27, 2026, 11:00 a.m.CapricorCommenting on the FDA's briefing materials, Capricor says post hoc analyses in them "rely on SAP version 1.1, an unsigned incomplete internal draft".Capricor release
July 30, 2026, 9:30 a.m.CapricorCapricor reports that at the public meeting on July 29, 2026 the committee voted "(3 for, 9 against, 0 abstain)", and says the voting question "addressed a narrower indication than Capricor had proposed".Capricor release
August 24, 2026, 9:25 a.m.CapricorCapricor says the PDUFA date moved from August 22 to November 22, 2026, after a BLA amendment with 24-month open-label extension data from HOPE-3.Capricor release
November 20, 2026, 7:55 p.m.CapricorCapricor announces a second CRL. It says the FDA "does not consider the data sufficient to establish substantial evidence of effectiveness" and "cites certain other clinical deficiencies". The release gives no date for the letter.Capricor release

Closes around each disclosure

CAPR daily closes (FMP end-of-day, split-adjusted, read November 22, 2026), the last close before each disclosure against the first close after it. Recorded history, not a forecast.

DisclosureWhen (ET)Close beforeClose afterChange
First CRL announced2025-07-11 6:30 a.m., before the open$11.40 (July 10)$7.64 (July 11)-33.0%
Capricor responds to the FDA's posting of the letter2025-09-09 9:20 a.m., before the open$6.35 (September 8)$6.48 (September 9)+2.0%
Type A meeting outcome2025-09-25 7:15 a.m., before the open$6.19 (September 24)$6.52 (September 25)+5.3%
HOPE-3 topline2025-12-03 7:20 a.m., before the open$6.36 (December 2)$29.96 (December 3)+371.1%
Class 2 resubmission, new PDUFA date2026-03-10 9:25 a.m., before the open$30.63 (March 9)$33.40 (March 10)+9.0%
FDA briefing materials posted; Capricor comments on themCapricor's comments 2026-07-27 11:00 a.m., during the session; when the FDA posted the materials is not in these sources, and the span includes the weekend of July 25 and 26$19.70 (July 24)$7.00 (July 27)-64.5%
Advisory committee vote (July 29)vote at the public meeting 2026-07-29; Capricor's release 2026-07-30 9:30 a.m., at the open; the price file shows no volume on July 29$6.57 (July 28)$4.19 (July 30)-36.2%
PDUFA date extended2026-08-24 9:25 a.m., before the open$6.29 (August 21)$6.80 (August 24)+8.1%
Second CRL announced2026-11-20 7:55 p.m., after the close$7.59 (November 20)first session after: November 23, 2026not yet traded

Decision pages: July 2025 CRL · November 2026 CRL · facts from all released CRLs · every released CRL.